Bell-to-bell cellphone bans benefit students
For those school-based hours, Acton graduates should experience boredom and face-to-face communications.
Acton schools just began a long-term project called Vision of a Graduate. But responsible, intentional technology practices are needed now. To realize a vision of engaged, attentive, and happier graduates, our schools should whitelist computer applications and ban cellphones bell to bell.
When my elementary student received a school computer, the device had basically no restrictions. We received no instructions for preventing YouTube watching and addictive game-playing, while simultaneously doing homework. School WiFi blocks some distracting and dangerous websites. But at home, restrictions are technically challenging. In 2024, Acton Middle School wisely restricted overnight laptop usage — hopefully, this policy endures.
Employers expect graduates to utilize work computers for work. They monitor and track employees’ usage. Intentional, responsible technology practice should begin in school. Instead of selective blocking, schools should whitelist robust, educational resources.
Unenforced cellphone policies enable students to rely on that screen in their pocket or on their wrist to satisfy boredom. They can quickly type and share the first thought that comes to mind. Students should not use moments of spare time to check notifications and send messages. Rather, they should smile at or greet a classmate, notice a new person in the room or hallway, or observe a sad or angry friend.
Similar to the days of mask-wearing, when some students found comfort by hiding their faces, cellphones can conceal students’ words, thoughts, and feelings. For those school-based hours, Acton graduates should experience boredom and face-to-face communications. Local private schools have realized value from bell-to-bell policies. High schools from Brockton to Louisville to San Mateo ban cellphones. A California principal said her kids have “grown to value being in the moment.”
Unrestricted computer use fosters addiction. Handy social media facilitates hate speech and enables bullying. Let’s join the groundswell of sensible school technology policies to make that vision a reality.
Gail Hire
Nancy Road
